← All posts
How USCIS Reviews O-1A Evidence in Two Steps
An officer first checks whether the petition meets the minimum number of criteria or shows a qualifying award, then weighs all the evidence together. At the second step, evidence outside the 8 criteria can count too.
Last reviewed against the USCIS Policy Manual on
Step 1: the evidence threshold
“More specifically, an officer first determines whether the petitioner has submitted evidence meeting the minimum number of criteria or submitted evidence that the beneficiary received a qualifying award (or nomination, if applicable).”
“As explained in the preamble to the final rule, the evidentiary requirements are not the standard for the classification, but are instead the mechanism for establishing whether the standard is met.”
Step 2: the totality of the evidence
“At this step, officers may consider any potentially relevant evidence, even if such evidence does not fit one of the above regulatory criteria or was not presented as comparable evidence.”
The Policy Manual gives examples of evidence officers may weigh at this step, including these two:
“The petitioner provides evidence demonstrating that the total rate of citations to the beneficiary’s body of published work is high relative to others in the field, or the beneficiary has a high h-index for the field.”
“The record establishes that the beneficiary has received unsolicited invitations to speak or present research at nationally or internationally recognized conferences in the field.”
Context is the petitioner's job
“In all cases, the petitioner has the burden of providing sufficient context regarding the above evidence and considerations to demonstrate that the evidence meets the relevant criteria and to establish the beneficiary’s extraordinary ability in the totality of the circumstances.”
Frequently asked questions
- If I meet 3 criteria, is my O-1A approved?
- Not automatically. Meeting the criteria is the first step; the Policy Manual says the evidentiary requirements are the mechanism for establishing whether the standard is met, not the standard itself.
- Does my h-index matter for an O-1A?
- The Policy Manual lists a high citation rate or a high h-index for the field as evidence officers may consider in the totality of the evidence.
- Do speaking invitations count?
- Unsolicited invitations to speak or present research at nationally or internationally recognized conferences are one of the Policy Manual's examples for the totality step.
Related
Quotes are word for word from the USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 2, Part M. Practitioner tips are common practice, not USCIS rules. For informational purposes only, not legal advice.